Final Reflection by Tammy Flanders
In reviewing the workshops, we taught over the last two weeks, both Paula and I feel more certain that sticking with the Three Little Pigs scenario for both the secondary and elementary level students will be the way to go in the future. The feedback we got from the two classes of secondary students who had the opportunity to work through both scenarios felt it was the one that facilitated their understanding more. However, I feel sure that we will get push back from some secondary students who will see the fairy tale scenario as being too juvenile. It will be up to Paula and me to ensure that the focus is on the design thinking process and NOT on the task. We just have to make it known to the students.
Upon further reflection, we feel that offering two examples of design thinking (one being the IDEO video where a shopping cart is redesigned and two, displaying our own work as represented in the workshop) is worthwhile. The shopping cart is a great example because the process results in a concrete object that has obviously undergone some significantly physical changes. It is easy to see the prototype.
Presenting the workshop as a second example demonstrates what a less concrete application might look like. When students are trying to tie the design thinking process to their own classroom practice according to their curriculum specializations (humanities vs. science, math, and kinesiology) there is often a struggle as to what this will look like. Prototyping is so strongly associated with producing a product that it becomes difficult to know that ‘thing’ looks like when it is not concrete. In the humanities especially, the prototype or product might not be an actual physical thing. It might be a concept, a program or a workshop.
Final Reflection by Paula Hollohan
After all the Design Thinking workshops we did, I firmly believe one thing. As student teachers this explanation of the process must be experienced and that experience can be the lens through which you see the curriculum.
Students will be going through a few projects to live the design thinking process. At the end of these five weeks, design thinking will be a lived experience for each of them.
As students prepare for their final practicum and for their own classrooms in September, it will be interesting to see which parts of the curriculum they view “through the lens of design thinking.”
Elementary specialists may feel they have the luxury of time for their students to really experience design thinking. Secondary students, who feel their time is more regimented, may have to begin by seeing one curriculum unity through the design thinking lens.
Most articles cite the remarkable engagement of students in every grade who are tasked with learning with design thinking. The adoption may be slow in secondary but will be fed through the invested, engaged students led by engaged teachers.
We do want you to visit our Research Guide about Design Thinking and Makerspaces. Also visit our blogs that provide curated resources for various classroom settings. Tammy’s blog is Apple with Many Seeds and Paula’s blog is Doucette Ed Tech. We also have a variety of resources showcased through Pinterest Boards and some technology ideas collected on these boards. All of these resources can be accessed even after graduation and are updated fairly regularly.
It was a great experience to teach the Design Thinking process to so many students and to have so much feedback on the process. The count down is on for next year’s iteration.